Michael Shannon Taylor

Statement of the Federal Defender for the Middle District of Alabama on the Execution of Michael Shannon Taylor

Posted on: Thu, November 5, 2026

Tonight, the State of Alabama executed Michael Shannon Taylor. We carry a deep sorrow tonight, and it is a sorrow shared by two families.

We grieve with the family of Ivan “Ernest” and Lucille Moore. Nothing can make them whole. For thirty-five years they have carried a loss, and a pain, that no family should ever have to endure. They carry it still tonight, and we hold them in our hearts. Michael knew the depth of the harm he caused. He never asked anyone to forget it, and he grieved it for the rest of his life.

We grieve, too, with Michael’s family and friends, and with the many people who loved him: the pastors and church volunteers who kept coming back, the men on the row who walked beside him, and everyone who refused to give up on him. Years after losing his mother while he was in prison, his family has now lost him too.

Our office has represented Michael since 2017. The man we knew was not the nineteen-year-old who committed this crime in 1991. He was bright and funny, a lover of trivia and sports statistics, a fan of Notre Dame and the Pittsburgh Steelers, and a man who, after years of struggle, found a deep and genuine faith. Ronald Wyers, a prison ministry volunteer who came to know him, said of Michael’s faith: “He understands it and he sends it forward, not being a reservoir but a river.” Michael grew in a place that offers no programs and no path to growth. He grew up in prison because people there showed up for him.

At Michael’s trial, the prosecutor told the jury that Michael was “not even the prodigal son.” Michael said the parable that tells his story best comes a few verses earlier in the same chapter of Luke: the shepherd who leaves the ninety-nine to go after the one sheep that is lost, and does not stop until he finds it. So many people went after Michael, and he was found. Like the shepherd who called his friends together and said, “Rejoice with me; for I have found my sheep which was lost,” those who helped Michael find his way to Christ shared in the joy of his salvation.

Serious questions about tonight’s execution remain unanswered. Michael gave up his challenge to lethal injection in 2018 when the State promised he would be executed by the method he chose. After that method’s protocol was found unconstitutional, the State switched him back to the method he had given up challenging. Michael asked the courts whether the State could do that. On November 2, a circuit court ruled, without hearing any evidence, that it could. Michael appealed. Last night, the Alabama Supreme Court denied his request for a stay without explanation. No appellate court ever decided whether the State could lawfully break its promise to him.

We asked for mercy, and it was not granted. But Michael held fast to a greater grace, the one he found in Ephesians: “For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God” (Ephesians 2:8). We take comfort in knowing he faced tonight held by that grace.

Michael’s life was proof that God isn’t finished with any of us. Tonight we pray that both families find peace, and we deeply mourn the loss of Michael.